Sun 17 Jan 2010
James Cameron, I Smite Thee!
Posted by nerdmeyr under Cabinet of curios
[3] Comments
(for a much better and wholly more worthwhile movie review, see K’s takedown of Knowing.)
I can clearly remember a warm spring day in grade school when I walked down 117th Street to catch the school bus, and had James Brown’s _I Got You (I Feel Good)_ stuck in my head. It was stuck in my head because it is an song that in both composition and performance is unalterably, undeniably, and unaffectedly more catchy than white dog fur on a black peacoat. At that time, fresh in the world, James Brown was a revelation to me. Now, in my tender mid-thirties, it takes a long week and a serious Manhattan or two before Mr. Brown’s voice can move me in such a way. It is not just me growing old and calcified, it is the natural progression of de-sensitization. Over the course of my relatively short life, I have imbibed James Brown not just on the way home from the library in the back of my parent’s car, but in doctor’s offices, grocery stores, and wedding receptions. It is not James Brown’s fault that he no longer moves me… he has no opportunity for extemporaneous re-imaginings and re-workings of the iconical.
I imagine that if James Cameron were cowering before me, and I were wielding a jug of syrup and a bucket of fire ants, the one thing that might save his sorry, sorry and tembling ass would be him exclaiming, “I started that movie ten years ago!”
Perhaps it is not James Cameron’s fault that I found Avatar boring at best, completely reprehensible at worst. Perhaps it is that I have seen Contact, Requiem for a Dream, Girl Interrupted, and one of the Harry Potty serials. In other words, James, it’s not you. It’s me.
Avatar - food for the sewer rats
Now that I have done my due diligence in excusing Mr. Cameron, I let loose with my barrage of cutty-shark word complaints about my new favorite worst movie of the world, Avatar. There are those who argue that Avatar relies upon unfortunate-to-unforgivable racist elements . There are those who argue that Avatar represents an unfortunate re-hashing of a messiah complex. Yes, I agree. My biggest beef with Avatar, however, can be summarized thusly:
If you lack all imagination but can corral 2,500 CGI horses, make Avatar.
Aliens from a completely different universe? planetary system? whatever. Anyway, oh, wow, you came up with four-limbed, two-eyed, vertically symmetrical athletic carbon-based beauty-aliens that look like a cross between Keane Big Eyed kids, Tayshaun Prince of the Detroit Pistons, and the stilt-walking hippie who panhandles down on Pacific Ave. And who simultaneously perform their lives according to 21st century middle-class American standards of binary genders, heterosexuality, and ethnic eco-consciousness. Wow! That’s really out there! What??? You say you’re giving them braided hair with beads, iridescent facial tattoos, ear plugs, and bare feet???!? Waaait a minute… I feel like I’ve seen those features somewhere… oh yeah, like EVERY FREAKING DAY! On the bus, no less (now THERE’S an intergalactic space mission for you Mr. Cameron!) Oh, and they talk all mystical and wise and shit? Really??? And there are trees on this faraway distant space planet that look suspiciously like every giant-ass oak tree I’ve ever seen? And the military is all stompy and racist and act like tools for The Man, and anthropologists are all elitist and smug and clueless-about-real-life? But there’s this One Guy? Who’s Reluctant??! But Different? And (somehow) Special? Amazing! That’s…… so…….. unique………….
The bottom line for me is that this movie says absolutely nothing about race, class, colonialism, disability, liberalism, conservatism, agency, citizenship, or ANYTHING of interest. It can’t possibly, because its too busy farting and burping unicorns in the form of CGI effects. It relies upon every other action and space-alien movie ever made to make any sort of impact at all. I cannot abide laziness, truculence, or incuriousity, and this movie reeked of all three. This is a movie made by a sheltered man-child who substitutes trope and cliche and firework for inventiveness, uncertainty and nuance. Sometimes I dislike a movie; sure, whatever, OK. Then there are the movies which make me feel like their very popularity is a clarion call for Zeus to descend and incinerate all of us, because if this is what we produce in all of our wealth and glory and comfort, we deserve to be incinerated. This is that movie.




